Croker-Rhyne Co., Inc.

Main Page  |   Philosophy  |  Current Recommendations  |  Newsletter Archives
Contact Us

                                  

June 26, 2025

Gold’s same old Story…

I wrote what immediately follows here at the last major top (2012) in Gold…which became the high in Gold for the next 8 years. I’m not re-posting it to say, “Hey! Look how right I was,” as I make no secret of the fact that I can be just dead ass wrong in my recommendations as well. I’m repeating it here because I view today’s Gold market, and all of the “You GOTTA own it!” rhetoric, as being pretty much a word for word repeat of the same Wall Street hype that was there in December, 2012, as Gold was beginning a 40% FOUR YEAR DECLINE…

December 13, 2012

Precious Metals are like the Dotcom’s of 2000

Be Short Gold

In my opinion, this is where the real “Cliff” is…and $900-$1000 (or worse) Gold would not surprise me at all.

To my ears, believing in the ownership of Gold has become almost a speculative religion today. There are ever so many reasons to buy it, own it, keep it…even though its principal value is based on nothing more than the premise it will either go up, or hold its value. Everybody is recommending it, from PIMCO (Bond people!), to Soros, to Paulsen, to Deutsche Bank, Morgan Stanley, Goldman…you name it, everybody is on it. And I do not use “everybody” loosely…Check out these forecasts from various financial institutions in the last few months…I swear, I have NEVER seen a market with opinion so lopsided as it now is in Gold. NEVER. Not even close…

This is certainly not everybody on the planet, but when you note the big names on this list, and their bullish unanimity, you do have to ask:  Who could possibly be left to join this bandwagon? What NEW buying could possibly be out there to push this market higher again?

And my answer is NOBODY. In my mind, all you really have left is, you know who…the PUBLIC…the fodder for all those houses listed above. If Gold does fall out of bed, do you think ANY of these institutions will truly suffer from their opinions? Sure, there might be this or that “rogue trader” who gets his company in a pickle, but generally, the biggest losers will be individual investors…the guys who are forever on the short end of the stick, the guys who are influenced to make investing decisions based on the supposed market “knowledge” of ALL those supposedly smart guys at those well-known banks and brokerage houses, who are “logically”, confidently telling them, “You  gotta own some of this!”…And you KNOW how this story always seems to end.

The Game hasn’t changed. Even though Gold made its high over a year ago, Gold  ETF’s are now being owned in record numbers by the public…and wrong though I may be…If ALL the Banks and Brokerage Houses, and ALL the public buyers of those “easy to get in on this” ETF’s are right, and they ALL make money, I will be dumbfounded.

I firmly believe, ANY given day from here is where Gold begins one of its classic facerips….and faster than all this hoard of nouveau commodity traders could ever imagine, it will have blown through every “support” level any analyst wants to signify as “significant” on the chart.

I mean really…Forget all the “fundamental” reasons to own Gold. Look at the 35 year chart below…Does buying this here, especially when every “suit” on the planet is telling you to do so, really look like a smart idea?

I hate writing at length about any market…I know people just don’t want to read and read and read some old hack’s two cent thoughts but I suppose I have to at least briefly offer my own perspective on all these wonderful reasons why Gold will keep going higher…

There are 3 traditional reasons to ever own this metal: Inflation fears, Geopolitical Fears and the Failure of the World Economic System and its currencies as a monetary vehicle…and I think none of them are valid.

Inflation? I’ve heard that argument for 30 years…every time the Fed has been in an easing mode. They used to make a big hoorah about how expanding “Money Supply” was certainly going to lead to hyperinflation…which we never even came close to. Now it’s the QE programs, that according to all sorts of sophisticated logic (again) can only be inflationary. I’m not naïve, and I am being simplistic about this, and recognize the numbers are bigger this time around (but they ALWAYS are---just like you can’t buy a soft drink for a nickel anymore), but it’s all still just Central Bank Easing…providing grease to the system in the form of cheap money and liquidity…and WON’T lead to hyperinflation. Again,  I have heard this “Hyper-Inflation is just around the corner!” story forever…and even though there have been a few blips along the way, the big bad wolf has never really appeared. Nice economic theory but just textbook stuff, something else for everybody to chatter about.

On this next chart, check out the LACK of inflation in the CPI for the past 30 years, and maybe you don’t remember it but I do…I can’t count the occasions when almost every analyst in the world was warning about Fed easing leading to inflation…And it just hasn’t happened…And won’t.

Geopolitical Fears? Look back up at that long term chart…Gold went down from 1980 until 2000 and there were any number of geopolitical “crises” during those two decades, none of which produced a lasting bullish effect on the market. It was sideways to lower for TWENTY years. To me, this says the whole “bullish geopolitical” argument is either a myth, or at best, its effect is merely temporary.

The System Collapsing and Gold becoming the New Currency? One, the system is  NOT going under and any discussion along these lines is ludicrous…And as for gold being the New Currency, I am sure this may sound positively heretical to anyone who truly “believes” in gold, but in this day of instantaneous electronic billion dollar transfers, I think the idea of gold as some great measure of wealth is nothing more than an antiquated perception that is someday doomed to extinction. Yes, it’s a “rare” metal (not as abundant as coal, for example), and yes, it makes for beautiful, everlasting jewelry and trinkets, and yes, it is perceived as a repository of value…but to suppose it is going to become the currency of the world is, I  believe, an absurd notion…I see Gold as still just another commodity on the planet. We aren’t going to be lugging it around. And we aren’t going to be swiping debit cards based on any of us having “x” ounces of gold stashed away in some bank. It will always be worth more than many other commodities, but it WILL always do what they all do…GO UP and GO DOWN. Be HOT and be “NOT”.

IT’S JUST ANOTHER COMMODITY.

I don’t care what commodity you are talking about. Futures contracts almost ROUTINELY go through 30-50% contractions. However much “logic” you want to throw at me as to why “Gold can’t go down”, I will insist you are wrong…and I will also insist there is a strong possibility it could lose easily lose 30-40% of its value before we even halfway through 2013. Maybe I’m wrong…but I have seen far too many supposedly bulletproof markets suddenly turn into Bonnie and Clyde’s car when their jig was finally up. Gold CAN go down…and it can go down a lot…and for many years to come..

I do think Gold today is very much like the NASDAQ of 2000…that this story is old, old, old news. I hear talk of support at $1600, $1500, or whatever number any analysts want to pick, and having probably done more technical analysis than 99.9 % of the traders on this planet, I will tell you that any talk of this or that level being significant is a bunch of bunk. I have seen hundreds of markets, that, when the mob psychology switch gets thrown, just go straight  and relentlessly down…And with long gold being one of the most popularly widespread ideas I have ever seen, maybe I’m wrong but a relatively quick trip to under $1000 would not surprise me in the least. How quickly? Who knows? Maybe a year. Maybe three? But I think anyone who buys this commodity, and can only get a return on their investment if it goes up….and then they sell it, if they take the money….is going to end up living with a losing trade until the finally take their loss somewhere further down the “yellow brick road”.

I REPEAT: I THINK OWNING GOLD IS THE MOST POPULAR TRADE I HAVE EVER SEEN IN THIS BUSINESS. AND POPULAR IDEAS CAN BE LIKE POISON IN THIS FUTURES TRADING. 

And here is how it played out from there…

 

 

And back to the present…

 

You’re kidding yourself if you look at today’s market and think that, “It’s different this time.” Again…IT’S JUST ANOTHER COMMODITY…WITH ITS PRICE ACTION DOMINATED BY MOB OPINION MORE THAN ANYTHING ELSE…AND IT DOES GO BOTH UP…AND DOWN…AND QUITE OFTEN FOR YEARS AT A TIME. FADE THE CROWD!!! ESPECIALLY ALL OF THE NEW YORKS SHILLS. BE SHORT NOW.

 

As I’ve recently noted, IF THE MIDDLE EAST BLOWING UP DIDN’T RALLY GOLD, WHAT IN THE HELL WILL? And in this market? IF IT AIN’T GOING UP…THE NEXT THING IT DOES IS GO DOWN.

 

I STILL MAINTAIN THAT EVERYBODY WHO WOULD BE LONG IS ALREADY LONG THIS MARKET…NOT BECAUSE THEY NEED IT OR USE IT, BUT SIMPLY BECAUSE THEY BELIEVE THE INTERNET YAKHEADS ON WALL STREET…AND SO YOU HAVE A WHOLE MOB OF INVESTORS SITTING THERE LONG…AND WAITING FOR THE PROFITS TO ROLL IN…WHEN, IN REALITY, THE NEXT THING WE’LL START SEEING IS THE USUAL MASS LIQUIDATION SELLING AS GOLD SLIDES, THEN TRULY CRAPS OUT…SAME AS IT DID BACK IN 2012.

 

 

 

Experience has taught me, that when it comes to Gold and Silver, all ANYBODY ever thinks about is, “When do I buy it?” Knowing this, I expect no takers here…other than myself…But will say it one more time in hopes that some “fool” reading this might go along with me: GOLD AND SILVER DO GO DOWN…AND WHEN THEY DO, IT’S USUALLY BIG, FAST AND RELENTLESS.

 

Contact me if you’re interested.

 

Gracias,

Bill

 

770-425-7241

866-578-1001

 

All option prices in this newsletter include all fees and commissions. All charts, unless otherwise noted, are by Aspen Graphics and CRB.

 

FUTURES TRADING IS NOT FOR EVERYONE. THE RISK OF LOSS IN TRADING CAN BE SUBSTANTIAL. THEREFORE, CAREFULLY CONSIDER WHETHER SUCH TRADING IS SUITABLE FOR YOU IN LIGHT OF YOUR FINANCIAL CONDITION. PAST PERFORMANCE IS NOT INDICATIVE OF FUTURE RESULTS. THERE IS NO GUARANTEE YOUR TRADING EXPERIENCE WILL BE SIMILAR TO PAST PERFORMANCE.

 

The author of this piece currently trades for his own account and has a financial interest in the following derivative products mentioned within: Gold, Silver