Croker-Rhyne Co., Inc.

Main Page  |   Philosophy  |  Current Recommendations  |  Newsletter Archives
Contact Us

                                  

May 31, 2025

 

JUST BECAUSE THE WHITE HOUSE WANTS STOCKS TO GO HIGHER

DOES NOT MEAN THAN THEY WILL

 

JUST BECAUSE COMPANIES ARE MAKING MONEY

ALSO DOES NOT MEAN THAT STOCKS WILL GO HIGHER…

 

I VIEW THE RECENT 2 MONTH RALLY

AS A FINAL OPPORTUNITY TO SELL…

 

Last fall I began to express an opinion that, “EVERYBODY IS LONG EVERYTHING…Stocks (chips, NVIDA and AI in particular), Gold, Crypto, etc.”, that in essence, “EVERYBODY was IN,” which, in this giant mob psychology investment game, suggested to me that the next BIG move would be down…And this DID become the case in Stocks and Crypto…but ultimately, their sell offs were followed by fairly stout recoveries, with Bitcoin even making it all the way back to its old high…while Gold did keep climbing into April before making what I believe will prove to be its high for many years to come…Nevertheless, my current view is, that if anything, EVERYBODY IS EVEN MORE LONG THAN THEY WERE BEFORE…AND I CONTINUE TO RECOMMEND BEING SHORT ALL OF THESE MARKETS.

 

Aside from my belief that Trump’s scorched earth approach to economics and world trade will have disastrous consequences (It is HIGHLY significant that a recent survey showed that America’s CEO’s now have the lowest confidence in 50 years), I find it astounding that during the stock market decline and ensuing rally, individual investors (the public) were actually buying stocks like never before…as is reflected by this news excerpt from April 4th, the day after Liberation Day when the Dow had one of its biggest down days ever:

 

Individual investors (yesterday) bought stocks and ETFs at a record pace. Individuals made $4.7 billion worth of net equity purchases on April 3, meaning value of shares they bought outpaced the amount they sold by $4.7 billion. This is the highest daily inflow over the past decade…Retail investors' purchases were nearly evenly split between single stocks ($2.3 billion) and ETFs ($2.4 billion), with Nvidia and S&P 500 ETFs (SPY) among the top assets acquired.”

 

And then there was this (at last week’s top tick since the rally began):

 

“Retail investors on May 19 plowed $5.1 billion into US stocks, according to data from JPMorgan Chase. That’s the largest daily inflow into stocks from retail investors on record since data collection began in 2015.

 

 

In other words, in this investment GAME, in which 62% of Americans own stocks, and are probably now more long than they have ever been, not only have they been hanging on to what they already owned, but they have actually even been BUYING MORE in the face of an economy that is clearly endangered by the absurdity of 150% tariff threats, job liquidations, policy flipflopping, etc.…And yes, they have been rewarded (so far), but I’d offer that the last 30-40 days have NOTHING to do with where the market will be 3-6 months from now, and it is my guess that by year’s end, individual investors, who DO have an endless history of periodically getting “reamed” by Wall Street’s Banks and Brokerages, WILL find themselves having lost massively on just about everything they own, or have bought, up here at the market’s all-time highs.

 

 

On a specific note, it’s been a long time since I’ve seen one company, which was relatively unknown to the public just 2 years ago, so dominate the headlines…almost to the extent that New York and all the talking heads are equating its performance to what the whole damn stock market is going to do…and that is Nvidia…With that in mind, I’d say that ANY time any one name becomes so popular that it’s seemingly 90% of the financial news every day, it’s quite possible that, “everybody who would ever buy it, already has done so,” meaning that all the hoopla and “good earnings” in the world won’t be pushing it higher. And so when I look back at that May 19th “record daily inflow” excerpt above, noting  Nvidia and S&P 500 ETFs (SPY) among the top assets acquired,” all I can think is…one more time…EVERYBODY IS ALREADY IN.

 

MY RECOMMENDATION IS TO SHORT ANY, OR ALL THREE, OF THE STOCK INDEX FUTURES SHOWN ABOVE...WITH MY MINIMAL OBJECTIVES BEING NEW LOWS FOR THE YEAR IN EACH OF THEM.

 

GET SHORT GOLD

 

 

 

THE MARKET TO BUY?

US TREASURY BONDS


Of late, I note that maybe 98 out of every 100 Wall Street’s genius “strategists” are squawking about “too much US debt,” which is the same bearish argument I periodically heard from them for 40 years…from the Treasury market lows in 1980 until the all-time high in 2020…Beyond that, be assured that all of the recent chatter that, “The world has lost confidence in the USA and nobody is going to want our Bonds,” is absolute hogwash. Aside from the fact that our 30 Year Treasury has the second highest government backed yield on the planet, UNITED STATES TREASURY PAPER IS STILL INTERNATIONALLY REGARDED AS THE SAFEST SOVEREIGN DEBT THERE IS…AND FACT BE KNOWN, EVERY TIME WE HAVE A TREASURY AUCTION, FIXED INCOME BUYERS LINE UP TO BID ON IT. PERIOD.

 

All that being said, in the paper investment world, I’d remind you that there ARE two major instruments that are traded in the billions every single day…Stocks…and BONDS. Neither is going to disappear…and funds are CONSTANTLY flowing in and out of both of them as these two asset classes fluctuate in value…and quite naturally, there ARE times when their values, relative to each other, DO reach opposite extremes…and that, I firmly believe, is where we are now…that STOCKS ARE EXTREMELY OVERVALUED RELATIVE TO BONDS…AND IN THE MOST BASIC SENSE OF, “BUY LOW, SELL HIGH,” RIGHT NOW IS WHEN YOU SELL STOCKS…AND BUY BONDS.

 

 

 

Still Short Cattle


And yeah, this idea has beaten me to death…and I’ve repeated myself over and over…but I do not lose sight of what the 50 years of history indicate…that this market DOES go from bullish to bearish, virtually overnight on NO specific news event whatsoever…and when it does, the collapses ARE typically 20-25% within 2-3 months’ time…And with a move like that meaning something like 60-70 cents, or $30,000+ per futures contract, I WILL NOT BE OUT OF THIS TRADE…ESPECIALLY WHEN, LIKE RIGHT NOW, WE DO HAVE EVIDENCE OF A TOP TICK HAVING BEEN MADE…And yes, I have made that same observation before, and been wrong, BUT that does not mean I have it wrong again…

 

One more time…I will not be out of this as I KNOW, that literally from one trading day to the next, this market can suddenly be down 8-10 cents and rapidly on its way.

 

 

 

 

Still Recommend

Short Corn and Soybeans

My impression is that the whole ag world is convinced that bottoms have been made in both Corn and Soybeans. With massive crops are coming in both hemispheres, bullish farmers STILL hold tons of both crops from last fall (that DO represent a LOT of future selling)…and the backdrop of the destructive tariff situation, I SEE ANOTHER NEW LEG DOWN IMMEDIATELY AHEAD AS HEAVY SELLING COMES FROM EVERYWHERE.

 

 

 

Still Recommend LONG COTTON

 

Counterintuitively, Cotton often moves opposite the other major row crops…and I continue to see Cotton as having made a long term bottom. I still believe the July contract could have a big surge heading into expiration but our July Calls now have only 14 days to expiration, and I am now moving out in to the December contract…where I regard the calls as being dirt, dirt cheap relative to the fact that Cotton bull moves are typically no less than 30 cents in size.

 

 

Have Exited All Long Canadian Dollar Positions

 

I think that’s enough for one weekend…Thanks if you actually waded through all this…And I do URGE you to NOT ignore the opinions in Cattle, Corn and Soybeans as they all DO look primed for big moves…obviously especially in the Cattle puts, which aren’t cheap (but that, I think, is because of the enormous move they are about to make). As for Bonds, Gold and the Stock Indices, I definitely see them as fantastic big potential trades…but 45 years in this chair has taught me that very few people seemingly EVER want to Short Gold, or the Stock Indices…nor do they ever want to be Long Bonds (THE contrary opinion market), even on those occasions when their 40 year bull market made for incredible long trades.

 

Ring me up if you want to do any of this…or just want to tell me you think I am wrong.

 

Thanks,

Bill

 

770-425-7241

866-578-1001

 

All option prices in this newsletter include all fees and commissions. All charts, unless otherwise noted, are by Aspen Graphics and CRB.

 

FUTURES TRADING IS NOT FOR EVERYONE. THE RISK OF LOSS IN TRADING CAN BE SUBSTANTIAL. THEREFORE, CAREFULLY CONSIDER WHETHER SUCH TRADING IS SUITABLE FOR YOU IN LIGHT OF YOUR FINANCIAL CONDITION. PAST PERFORMANCE IS NOT INDICATIVE OF FUTURE RESULTS. THERE IS NO GUARANTEE YOUR TRADING EXPERIENCE WILL BE SIMILAR TO PAST PERFORMANCE.

 

The author of this piece currently trades for his own account and has a financial interest in the following derivative products mentioned within: All of them