Croker-Rhyne Co., Inc.

Main Page  |   Philosophy  |  Current Recommendations  |  Newsletter Archives
Contact Us

 

January 27, 2020

 

I have long believed that my opinion about the markets is not anywhere near as important as the math of how option prices can change, both positively and negatively…and this trade, I believe, drives that point home…more so than just about anything I have ever seen in this business.

Same as I wrote the first time I made this recommendation back in early 2017…This is a trade I think I will take for every year for the rest of my trading life…

My general opinion coming into 2020 has been, and is, that this year will ultimately be nothing but bullish for the USA’s main four row crops (Corn, Cotton, Soybeans and Wheat)…and for several months I have been looking at how to take those positions, pretty much coming to the conclusion (as I did last year as well) that the smart thing to do is simply buy summer dated calls in each one of them…and basically own all four markets as a single unit. Thereafter, by the math, one can assume that if just one of these markets has a solid bull move, and the three others totally die, there is an excellent possibility you could still come out with a net profit…And more optimistically, if 2, 3 or all 4 had the types of moves that I am expecting, you obviously could be looking at very attractive profits…Conversely, of course, if all four go wrong, you could lose every dollar you have invested…that is, you could lose 100% of what you put on the table.

But…Past experience has taught me that no matter how many times I present this sort of diversified “Buy all four” strategy, very few people ever do so…with the question I most frequently get being, “Which one do you like the most?” So, with this in mind, I’ll go straight to the single market that I think has the best odds, leverage and potential…

AND I FIRMLY RECOMMEND DOING THIS USING THE  “1 & 1” STRATEGY,

(OUTLINED WHEN I GET TO ACTUAL OPTIONS PRICES)

PER THE HISTORICAL DATA INCLUDED BELOW, THE MATH, TO ME, IS UNDENIABLE.

 USING the 1 & 1 (1 call & 1 put)

I AM BUYING JULY 2020 SOYBEAN MEAL

The bottom line, as you should be clearly able to see with both the individual charts…and summary table…is that MUCH more often than not, Soybean Meal (feed for livestock) has had what I would classify as a fairly sizable rally, at some point, between now and the contract’s end in early July…And I firmly believe the “1 & 1” (units of 1 call and 1 put) is the perfect strategy to definitely increase the odds of catching that rally, when, and of course, IF, it does occur…

The first thing, to get some idea of what possibly might happen, is to observe what this market has done for the past 19 years…So, What follows is every July Soybean Meal contract going back to 2000 (19 contracts) between mid-January and this contracts July expiration.

On each chart I have noted whatever rallies have taken place from mid-January forward…how big they were in Dollars, how big the move was in percentage terms, as well as the months in which the moves began and ended.

I will preface this historical data, however, by stating that anything that has happened during these past 19 years does NOT mean it will happen again…

That being said, my purely factual observation is that this market has had a DECIDED tendency to put up a strong rally between now and summer…and the moves are often quite direct…and NOT small. But I will again offer that these histories do not mean it will be the case in this year.

EVERY $1 MOVE IN SOYBEAN MEAL = $100 PER FUTURES CONTRACT – OR – EVERY $10 M0VE = $1000 PER FUTURES CONTRACT

So, note the size of the moves, when they began and ended…and how they actually did make the bull move…which, as previously noted, is often relatively straight up…

cid:image001.jpg@01D5C7B1.783B2AE0cid:image003.jpg@01D5C7B1.783B2AE0

    cid:image002.jpg@01D5C7B1.783B2AE02-7-17july2016meal.png

  2-7-17july2015soymeal.png  2-7-17july2014soymeal.png

  2-7-17july2013soymeal.png  2-7-17july2012soymeal.png

  2-7-17july2011soymeal.png  2-7-17july2010soymeal.png

  2-7-17july2009soymeal.png  2-7-17july2008soymeal.png

  2-7-17july2007soymeal.png 

  2-7-17july2005soymeal.png  2-7-17july2004soymeal.png

  2-7-17july2003soymeal.png  2-7-17july2002soymeal.png

  2-7-17july2001soymeal.png  2-7-17july2000soymeal.png

All charts in this study were created using Aspen Graphics

And yes, there are some big dollar moves here…which, aside from the high percentage number of years this market has had a strong rally, is one of the factors that definitely attracts me to this trade.

Here is a summation of what you see on those chart histories…And with today’s values for virtually all  commodities being notably higher than they were a decade ago, to me, the most important statistic here is HOW BIG THE PERCENTAGE MOVE WAS IN EACH OF THESE CONTRACTS…

Rallies in July Soybean Meal Mid-Jan to Expiration

Year

Size of move

$’s per

contract

Percent

change

Month

Started

Month of

High Tick

2019

$45

$4500

+16%

May

May

2018

$83

$8300

+26%

Jan

March

2017

$37

$3700

+12%

Jan

Jan

2016

$162

$16,200

+60%

April

June

2015

$86

$8600

+29%

June

July

2014

$115

$11,500

+29%

Jan

May

2013

$157

$15,700

+40%

April

July

2012

$176

$17,600

+56%

Jan

July

2011

$37

$3700

+11%

n/a

n/a

2010

$69

$6900

+27%

March

July

2009

$177

$17,700

+69%

March

June

2008

$132

$13,200

+40%

May

July

2007

$58

$5800

+30%

April

July

2006

none

n/a

n/a

n/a

n/a

2005

$86

$8600

+56%

Feb

June

2004

$102

$10,200

+43%

Feb

April

2003

$42

$4200

+26%

Jan

May

2002

$47

$4700

+33%

Feb

July

2001

$40

$4000

+28%

March

July

2000

$30

$3000

+19%

Jan

May

 

 Since 2000, in 15 of those 19 years, July Soybean Meal has had at least a 26% rally between mid-January and expirationwith the 4 exceptions being one year that only saw a 19% rally, one of 12% , one of 11%...and one “dead” year of nothing but sideways.

Considering the state of today’s futures markets, with billions in funds sloshing around on a daily basis…and the inherent volatility that seems to be the case in everything…MY OWN PERSPECTIVE IS THAT A 25% RALLY…FROM SOMEWHERE…SHOULD BE MY MINIMUM EXPECTATION. AND AT TODAY’S PRICES, IF THIS WERE TO BE THE CASE, THIS WOULD MEAN ABOUT A $75 RALLY, OR $7,500 PER FUTURES CONTRACT…Again this is predicated on my belief that something like this will happen, but certainly may NOT be what we see, which could mean losing up to 100% of what you have invested.

Why the 1 & 1 is perfect here…

To begin with, there is NO way to know if a rally is going to start from right here…or from $20-$30 or $40 lower…Nor is there any way to know exactly WHEN it might begin…And believe me, you are NOT going to figure out the timing by reading the news and thinking, “I’ll know when the bull move is starting and buy it then”. NO WAY. The point is, if it’s going on the upside, ANY up day can be the beginning of a bull move…and although we know, from the charts above, that LARGE RALLIES DO SEEM TO OFTEN OCCUR BETWEEN NOW AND JULY…and using the 1 & 1 does mean that if the first thing we see is a selloff, you DO have a decent shot at being able to recoup your original investment by selling the more valued puts and the lower valued calls…AND…then start all over again with totally new positions (new 1 & 1’s) at lower strike prices. PLAIN AND SIMPLE. And furthermore, if even then it continues to fall, which CAN be the case, you still will have the potential to reposition even lower…and BE THERE when/if this thing does do what it has done so many times…which is, at some point, to start one of those rallies that has occurred for 18 out the last 19 years…One more time, however...If you own this position, and the market goes sideways until July, you could lose everything you have on the table.

SO YOU PUT THIS POSITION ON NOW, WHILE WE ARE SITTING HERE AT 4 YEAR LOWS…AND FOLLOW THE 1 & 1 RULES:

Rule 1 – If the market goes the wrong way (down), and reaches the point where you are able to recoup 100% of your total investment by selling both the put and the call, you do so automatically. You do not start thinking, “Let’s see if it will go further and I can make some money going the ‘wrong’ way”. You take the money and start over with totally new positions...at better price levels.

Rule 2 – Exactly the opposite of Rule 1. If the market does start going the right direction (up), you do everything you can to leave it alone…and let it RUN. Do NOT start thinking, “It’s gonna pull back. I’ll get out here and get back in at a better prices”.

And the major point here is that if we do get, for example, just a 15% upswing…and again, we may not, believe me, you will not be crying about having “wasted” that money on the put...Conversely, if the market heads lower, you will thank your lucky stars that you bought the “defense.”

As I stated in the intro above, as much as I value my well researched, but not infallible, opinion, I have pointed out for years that the math and the statistics are much more important that any of the reasons anyone ever comes up with to either buy or sell any market…and I mean that…The numbers and how a trade can be worked are what counts…and I believe these are GREAT numbers. This is a SOLID idea, and whether it’s weather (which we know is getting more erratic) or demand or geopolitics or whatever, my firm belief is  that there are plenty of reasons to expect this market to do what it has done so many times in the past.

Here’s the big picture…

DOES 380 look like a big move from here?

And for what it’s worth, I don’t think the current market “angst” about Coronavirus is anywhere near as serious an issue as the Information Age Media is billing it as (everything seems to be touted as a “crisis”). Maybe it will affect some aspects of China’s or the World’s economies (like tourism or air travel for example…and temporarily…This is not Ebola), but I DON’T think it going to affect the quantity of Soybean Meal consumed by the world’s livestock population. Period. I don’t. Maybe I’m dead wrong but just don’t see that.

Here are the options I would recommend at today’s levels…

Again…I urge you to just look at the numbers…At what has been the tendency for this market  going back to 2000 (and further really)…And how the math of these options prices do work out…whether we go up, down, or sideways.

Call me if you want to talk about it.

Thanks,

Bill

770-425-7241
866-578-1001

All option prices in this newsletter include all fees and commissions.

FUTURES TRADING IS NOT FOR EVERYONE. THE RISK OF LOSS IN TRADING CAN BE SUBSTANTIAL. THEREFORE, CAREFULLY CONSIDER WHETHER SUCH TRADING IS SUITABLE FOR YOU IN LIGHT OF YOUR FINANCIAL CONDITION. PAST PERFORMANCE IS NOT INDICATIVE OF FUTURE RESULTS. THERE IS NO GUARANTEE YOUR TRADING EXPERIENCE WILL BE SIMILAR TO PAST PERFORMANCE.

The author of this piece currently trades for his own account and has a financial interest in the following derivative products mentioned within: Soybean Meal

 

Main Page   |  Philosophy  |  Current Recommendations  |  Newsletter Archives 
Contact Us